21 Sep
2017
21 Sep
'17
3:55 a.m.
If in speech there is a special tone to show when {X Y} means "Y which is X" and not "Y of X", it may (ask Okrand) be an idea to put a mark between the words to show this in writing, as in the book name "paq'batlh". ----Original message----
From : sustel@trimboli.name
On 9/20/2017 11:48 AM, Anthony Appleyard wrote:
Basically, if X and Y are nouns, when does "X Y" mean "X's Y", "Y of X", and when it is an apposition? In the old days I used to write "X 'oHbogh Y" for "X which is Y".
How would I translate "Maltz's captain" and "Captain Maltz" distinctively? It seems that {matlh HoD} could mean both.
Context, tone of voice, waggling of eyebrows. There is no way to tell them apart strictly through their grammar.