Am 10.10.2017 um 17:20 schrieb SuStel:

Do I know for sure that it's right? No, but it /feels/ right, it doesn't violate any rules, and it is unmistakable.

That's what you always blame me for doing. Gotcha! :-P

I'm not advocating generalizing the example, only saying that it feels right to me. I'm not trying to convince anyone to use it or to accept it. When you make "feeling" statements, some rule or observed feature is always a casualty. "I feel like third-person object prefixes should participate in the prefix trick, and I'm going to twist Okrand's very clear explanation into something that supports that." My "feeling" statement here breaks no rule, tosses out no canon, AND has precedent, and I'm not even trying to convince anyone it's right. It's JUST a feeling.

So no, not the same thing.

-- 
SuStel
http://trimboli.name