[tlhIngan Hol] Using -ta' during -taHvIS

[De'vID]

On Wed, 27 Feb 2019 at 17:40, SuStel <sustel at trimboli.name> wrote:

> On 2/27/2019 10:46 AM, Will Martin wrote:
>
> We all hate the rule.
>
> Speak for yourself, not others. I don't hate the rule; I think it adds
> character to the language.
>
I don't "hate" the rule either. I just often forget it's there.

> Don't speak for Klingons, either. You don't know that this is the Klingon
> equivalent of *whom.* You can't go declaring that it's disappearing from
> Klingon because you don't like it. Okrand has given us some indication of
> language change in *KGT,* and perfective on the second verb is not one of
> the things he says is happening.
>
The fiction that we agree to is that Okrand is describing Klingon as
spoken. But it's actually spoken over a period of centuries on the shows,
all the way from just before the TOS era (in Enterprise and Discovery) to
the end of the TNG era. TKD describes Klingon as allegedly related by
Maltz, and it says that you can't have an aspect suffix on the second verb
in a SAO construction. The two SkyBox cards are about the TNG era. Within
our fiction, who wrote those cards, and in whose Klingon (and what time
period's) were they written? It could conceivably be the case that the rule
has changed or relaxed by the time of TNG, which is why {moj 'e' wuqta'}
and {luDub 'e' lunIDtaH} are allowed. Or maybe it's allowed in Gowron's
dialect, and not in Kruge's, and became illegal again after Gowron was
deposed by Worf.

Of course, we don't know, so nobody should go around declaring that this is
so. But Okrand's hints about language change and his invention of dialects
has given us (actually, him) a lot of leeway to excuse inconsistencies.

(In-universe Okrand must be a time-traveler, because not only is he an
active linguist all the way from the TOS through the TNG era, but he's
somehow also made communication with Maltz possible in the late 20th/early
21st century.)

-- 
De'vID
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.kli.org/pipermail/tlhingan-hol-kli.org/attachments/20190227/b2c84b07/attachment-0031.htm>